Fans slam confusing plot of BBC Shetland finale

In Scotland, the BBC crime drama Shetland aired its final episode of the latest series, prompting significant backlash from its fans. Viewers expressed confusion over the plot, which seemed disconnected from the preceding episodes. Douglas Henshall, who had portrayed DI Jimmy Perez from 2013 to 2022, announced his exit from the show, leaving audiences shocked as his character rode off with partner Meg. Transitioning from Henshall's character, Alison O'Donnell now plays Alison 'Tosh' McIntosh, recently elevated to the role once held by Perez. This shift in characters may have affected audience reception, particularly since long-term fans had invested emotionally in the previous storyline. As the last episode unfolded, many familiar viewers took to social media to voice their frustrations, claiming that the narrative was poor, the acting disappointing, and the overall conclusion left them unsatisfied. Commenters noted that they felt as if the finale diverged significantly from earlier parts of the show, leading some to express a lack of interest in future seasons. O'Donnell herself reflected on taking over the beloved series, admitting she was anxious about replacing such a well-regarded character. She acknowledged the strong connection fans have to the show and its setting, emphasizing the Shetland Isles' unique qualities. However, her comments did not prevent fans from questioning the quality of the final series, with some asserting that it was the weakest season they have experienced. Ultimately, the emotional investment in the characters and the plot drove viewers to express disappointment, and many indicated they would likely not return for another series.