Four Seas Ice Cream shop sold after decades of Cape Cod legacy

In Centerville, Cape Cod, an iconic ice cream shop has recently changed ownership. The well-known Four Seas Ice Cream, established in 1934, has been sold after being on the market for $3 million. The sale was finalized on Wednesday by the real estate company Carey Commercial Inc. although the specifics regarding the sale price and terms remain undisclosed. The new owners, Josh and Leslie McElhattan, expressed their commitment to maintaining the ethos of the business that has been a staple in the community for decades. Doug Warren and his wife Peggy have managed the shop since 2000 and emphasized the importance of continuity in operations during the sale process, a sentiment echoed by the new owners who have background experience in the ice cream industry. Although the shop was up for sale, it continued to operate, showcasing dishes of their beloved homemade ice cream flavors, which include black raspberry, cookie dough, chip chocolate, and penuche pecan. This reputation for quality offerings contributed to significant interest, with over 40,000 inquiries made regarding the property, highlighting the long-standing popularity of the ice cream parlor. Four Seas Ice Cream is noted as the third oldest ice cream shop in New England, a fact that underscores its historical and cultural significance. The shop has attracted numerous celebrities over the years and was recognized as one of the top 50 ice cream shops in Massachusetts as voted by WBZ-TV viewers in 2021. The new ownership aims to honor this legacy and continue the tradition of providing high-quality ice cream products to loyal customers and those who discover the shop anew.