NYPD dismisses over 400 misconduct cases in 2023

In 2023, the NYPD dismissed over 400 substantiated misconduct cases, including numerous stop-and-frisk complaints, without conducting any reviews. These cases had been fully investigated by the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) and were sent to the NYPD for potential disciplinary action. The dismissals are particularly concerning as the NYPD is still under federal monitoring due to past issues with the stop-and-frisk policy, which has faced significant scrutiny and criticism. The practice of dismissing cases without review began three years ago as a response to increasing caseloads and the need to meet deadlines for disciplinary actions. Critics argue that this approach allows the department to evade accountability, as the NYPD claims it requires more time to review cases, citing the statute of limitations that mandates action within 18 months of an incident. This has led to accusations of irresponsibility and a lack of transparency in handling complaints. The CCRB has faced challenges in processing cases, often due to the NYPD withholding evidence, which has contributed to delays in investigations. As a result, the CCRB has had to close numerous cases without thorough investigations. This situation has prompted calls from City Council members for reforms, including stripping the police commissioner of certain powers related to case retention. Despite the NYPD's defense of its policies, the ongoing dismissal of substantiated misconduct cases raises serious concerns about the department's commitment to accountability and public trust, as well as the implications for community relations in New York City.