Onana's Struggles at Man Utd Compared to Raya's Success at Arsenal

Andre Onana joined Manchester United from Inter Milan in 2023 for £43.8 million, taking over the role of goalkeeper previously held by David de Gea. Despite high expectations due to his strong distribution and passing skills, Onana has struggled to perform at the level anticipated by fans and analysts alike. David James, a former England goalkeeper, has expressed frustration with Onana's performances, stating that he has not showcased the abilities that led to his signing. James believes that Onana's underwhelming form raises questions about the coaching staff, particularly Erik ten Hag, and whether they are effectively utilizing his talents. In contrast, David Raya, who was signed by Arsenal, is reportedly thriving in his role and fulfilling the potential that the club saw in him. James highlighted that Raya is currently performing at his best, which stands in stark contrast to Onana's situation at United. This comparison underscores the differing trajectories of the two goalkeepers since their respective transfers. James emphasized that Onana is not currently among the top six goalkeepers in the Premier League, despite his capabilities. He expressed hope that Onana can improve and reach the level expected of him, as he believes the player has the potential to succeed. The ongoing struggles of Onana at Manchester United have led to disappointment among fans and pundits, who anticipated a transformative impact from his arrival. The situation raises broader questions about player adaptation to new environments and the role of coaching in maximizing talent. As Onana continues to seek improvement, the spotlight remains on his performances and the expectations surrounding his role at Manchester United.