How Ulva’s community buyout dream turned sour

In 2018, the isle of Ulva, located off the coast of Mull, was purchased by the local community after a controversial intervention by the Scottish government. The island was initially listed for sale at £4.5 million by its owner, Jamie Howard, who had secured a private buyer. However, the Scottish government intervened, blocking the sale to facilitate a community buyout following expressed interest from local residents. This buyout was part of a broader land reform initiative aimed at empowering communities in Scotland. Despite the initial optimism surrounding the community buyout, residents have reported significant issues since the acquisition. Many locals are facing problems with the water supply, describing it as filthy and brown, which raises concerns about health and sanitation. Additionally, there are complaints regarding a lack of necessary repairs and maintenance on the island, leading to a decline in living conditions. The situation has sparked criticism among residents, who feel that the promises made during the buyout process have not been fulfilled. The community's hopes for a revitalized and self-sustaining island have been overshadowed by these ongoing challenges. As the community grapples with these issues, questions arise about the effectiveness of community buyouts and the support provided by the government. The experience of Ulva may serve as a cautionary tale for other communities considering similar initiatives, highlighting the complexities and potential pitfalls of such endeavors.