Conclave process proves to be an effective method for papal selection
- Robert Harris, the author of 'Conclave,' draws parallels between the conclave's secretive process and a reality TV show.
- He advocates for a more intimate and informed selection process for leadership positions.
- Harris's insights reveal both the strengths and weaknesses of the conclave system and emphasize the need for female representation.
In the wake of Pope Francis' death, discussions about the papal conclave process have resurfaced. Robert Harris, author of the novel 'Conclave,' highlighted the unique dynamics of this centuries-old ritual held in the Sistine Chapel. He emphasizes that the secrecy surrounding the voting provides an environment that can yield surprising results. Harris suggests that instead of broader public elections, a select group of people who are familiar with the candidates should determine the leader. His observations come after gaining rare access to areas of the Vatican usually restricted to outsiders, which allowed him to better understand the conclave's workings. Harris compares the conclave's dynamics to a reality television show, where contestants must identify contestants among them. He believes that this analogy holds true in the inner workings of the conclave, facilitating a serious decision-making process under pressure. He expresses confidence in the process, suggesting that the popes elected in such a manner have, over time, demonstrated their leadership abilities. Furthermore, Harris acknowledges the lack of female representation within the conclave process. He created the character Sister Agnes in his novel to voice the concerns of women, as their roles are often limited to service positions within the Vatican. This commentary highlights a significant issue in the Church's historical and ongoing practices regarding women's roles. John Allen, a Vaticanista, has critiqued the popular film adaptation of Harris' novel, noting that while it captures some truth about the cardinal voting process, much of it does not reflect reality. Unlike political elections, which occur regularly, a papal conclave only happens upon the death of a sitting pope, marking a special occasion that attracts global attention. The upcoming conclave is anticipated due to the recent passing of Pope Francis, prompting deeper analysis of both the fictional and historical aspects of this significant event.