Tanner Bibee exits game with leg cramps but Guardians still win

In Toronto, on May 4, 2025, Cleveland Guardians' right-hander Tanner Bibee pitched effectively for five innings in a tight matchup against the Blue Jays before being forced to exit the game due to cramping in both legs. During the warm-up for the bottom of the sixth inning, Bibee showed signs of discomfort, prompting the trainer to come to the mound. He had pitched well until that point, allowing three runs—two of which were earned—and five hits while striking out three and walking two batters. Despite his departure, he left the game with a narrow 4-3 lead, highlighting his contribution to the game before his untimely exit. Following Bibee’s departure, left-hander Tim Herrin took over on the mound. The Guardians had a robust performance despite losing their starting pitcher, as they managed to maintain their lead throughout the game. Notably, Gabriel Arias stood out offensively with three hits and two runs batted in (RBIs), playing a crucial role in the team's offense. The game maintained its competitive nature, culminating in a close finish with the Guardians ultimately defeating the Blue Jays 5-4, showcasing their resilience. Additionally, the team saw the return of six-time All-Star José Ramírez, who had missed the previous game due to a right ankle sprain; however, he struggled at the plate in his return, going 0 for 4 with a walk. The Guardians’ performance also displayed their effective pitching strategy, notably under the presiding conditions that saw Toronto batters secure three hits with runners in scoring position against Bibee, a notable comparison to his previous outings where he had allowed similar adjustments only once in the past six starts combined. With this victory, Bibee improved his record to 3-2 for the season and maintained an unblemished 3-0 record over three career starts against the Blue Jays. Lastly, the Guardians showed their depth and capability to perform under pressure, with other pitchers, such as Hunter Gaddis, stepping up effectively to preserve the lead, thereby affirming the team's tenacity and determination amidst the setbacks faced during the game.