Miami judge dismisses lawsuit against commissioner Carollo over free speech rights

A Miami-Dade Circuit Judge dismissed a lawsuit aimed at removing Commissioner Joe Carollo from office, which alleged he infringed on the free speech rights of two Little Havana businessmen, Bill Fuller and Martin Pinilla. The lawsuit claimed that Carollo violated the Miami City charter, which mandates forfeiture of office for public officials who violate citizens' rights. The judge ruled that Carollo was acting in an individual capacity, thus the challenge to his office was not valid. The businessmen had previously won a multimillion-dollar judgment against Carollo, who they accused of targeting them due to their support for a rival political candidate. Following the dismissal, Carollo's attorney expressed satisfaction, stating the lawsuit lacked merit. However, Fuller and Pinilla's legal representative indicated plans to appeal the ruling, emphasizing the importance of enforcing citizens' rights. In a related ruling, another judge determined that Carollo's wages could not be garnished to satisfy the $63.5 million judgment awarded to the businessmen in a separate civil case. This decision further complicates Carollo's legal challenges, as he continues to face scrutiny over his actions as a public official. The ongoing legal battles highlight tensions in Miami's political landscape, particularly between Carollo and the Little Havana business community. The outcome of the appeal could have significant implications for both the commissioner and the rights of citizens in the city, as it raises questions about the accountability of public officials.