Julian Castro urges Trump supporters to thank undocumented immigrants

On November 28, 2024, in the United States, several liberal figures emphasized the contributions of undocumented immigrants during Thanksgiving. Julian Castro, the former mayor of San Antonio and former Obama administration official, made a notable statement on social media, urging conservatives and supporters of President-elect Donald Trump to acknowledge the undocumented workers who harvest the food served at their Thanksgiving dinners. Castro's remarks sparked significant backlash, with many questioning the relevance of immigrant labor in regions like New York City and Chicago, where many migrants are concentrated but not necessarily engaged in agricultural work. In a related discussion on MSNBC, Representative Robert Garcia from California highlighted the vital role immigrant labor plays in the agricultural sector. He stated that nearly half of the farmworkers in the U.S. are noncitizens, and pointed out the potential economic consequences of mass deportations if implemented by the incoming Trump administration. This would not only affect farmworkers but also food service workers, many of whom lack legal status. Garcia referred to the idea of deporting these essential workers as "inhumane" and "un-American," underlining their crucial contributions to the economy and to many American families. As the Thanksgiving holiday approached, the discourse surrounding immigration and labor intensified, with some liberal advocates positioning this holiday as a moment to reflect on the contributions of immigrants to American society. In a related comment, actor John Fugelsang referenced historical figures, suggesting that the spirit of Thanksgiving lies in acknowledging those who contribute to society, regardless of their legal status. The discussions reflect broader themes in American immigration policy debates, especially during transitional political periods. The incoming Trump administration is expected to continue advocating for stricter immigration policies, which many argue could undermine the livelihoods of countless families and essential workers in various sectors. The reactions to Castro's remarks highlight the divisiveness of the immigration issue, as supporters and opponents of current policies clash over the narrative surrounding immigrants' roles in society, particularly during major holiday celebrations.