NFL Rookie Quarterback Rankings Heat Up After Preseason Debuts
- OutKick ranks NFL rookie quarterbacks after their first preseason games.
- Caleb Williams emerges as the top rookie quarterback in the rankings.
- Williams showcases promising skills in the preseason game.
As the NFL preseason unfolds, excitement surrounds the rookie quarterback class, particularly with standout performances shaping early rankings. Leading the pack is the Chicago Bears' quarterback, who showcased his potential with several impressive throws during his debut, earning him the top position in the 2024 NFL Rookie QB Rankings. Meanwhile, Daniels had a limited appearance, taking only 11 snaps, while Nix delivered the most notable first start among rookies, though one impressive outing alone does not elevate him above Williams and Daniels. McCarthy also made a strong impression in his preseason debut, ranking just behind Nix. He demonstrated resilience by standing firm against a defender to complete a significant pass, despite throwing an interception that slightly marred his performance. His ability to recover from setbacks is a promising sign for his development as a young player. In contrast, Drake Maye struggled in his first NFL preseason outing, primarily executing check-down passes during his brief one-series appearance. While some analysts believe Maye has a higher ceiling than Michael Penix, who has yet to convince skeptics of his starting potential, Maye's initial performance raised concerns about his readiness for the league. Penix, on the other hand, displayed quick decision-making and efficiency, although he too received mixed reviews. Despite one strong play, some observers feel the hype surrounding him may be overstated, suggesting a need for a more measured evaluation of his capabilities as an NFL quarterback.