Israel and U.S. pull negotiators as Hamas fails to respond constructively

In Qatar, the negotiation teams from Israel and the United States withdrew from ongoing discussions with Hamas. This decision, made on Thursday, July 24, 2025, follows nearly three weeks of mediation efforts in Doha that were deemed unproductive. U.S. Special Envoy to the Middle East Steve Witkoff indicated that the Trump administration is reassessing its negotiating strategy, expressing concerns over Hamas's lack of coordination and good faith in the negotiations. Israeli officials noted that the withdrawal does not result in a total breakdown of talks, stating there was no explosion or collapse, despite significant disagreements. A key point of contention has been Hamas's unwillingness to discuss demilitarization or potential resolutions to the conflict. Israeli sources point out that Hamas had proposed an exchange of 200 Palestinian security prisoners for 10 Israeli hostages, which was firmly rejected by Israel. The situation underscores the complexities of the conflict as both Israel and Hamas continue to hold firm positions regarding their respective demands. Israel insists on unconditional guarantees for security and the return of all hostages, while Hamas demands an end to the war and significant political concessions. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has emphasized that Israel's commitment to its war goals remains unchanged. He warned that if Hamas interprets Israel's inclination to negotiate as a sign of weakness, they are mistaken. Despite the current pause in discussions, Israeli negotiators plan to maintain contact with mediators from their home country. Both U.S. and Israeli officials have acknowledged the efforts of Qatari and Egyptian mediators, who have been essential in facilitating dialogue. Although the future of negotiations remains uncertain, the unresolved issues highlight the deep-rooted tensions and the challenges both parties face in achieving a sustainable resolution.