Critics react to Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick's sequel Another Simple Favor

In a highly anticipated follow-up, Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick return to their roles in the sequel to 2018's hit film A Simple Favor, titled Another Simple Favor. This film is set in Italy, where Stephanie Smothers, portrayed by Kendrick, and Emily Nelson, played by Lively, reconnect during Emily's lavish wedding to a wealthy Italian businessman on the picturesque island of Capri. The film intertwines themes of glamour with elements of murder and betrayal, leading to unexpected twists, making the wedding far from ordinary. Director Paul Feig, who also directed the original film, reunites with the leading actresses in this new installment, bringing forth a narrative that feeds off the chemistry between the two characters. Another Simple Favor incorporates a mix of comedy, mystery, and challenges set against a stunning backdrop, appealing to fans of the first movie while potentially attracting new audiences. Reviews so far indicate that the film has received an 81% 'fresh' rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 37 reviews, suggesting a generally positive reception. Critics have acknowledged the sequel's dependency on the charm of its predecessor. The Rotten Tomatoes Critics Consensus states that the film successfully combines mystery, charm, and humor, making for an engaging viewing experience. However, opinions vary with some critics expressing concerns that the follow-up lacks the original's spark, citing a diminishing creativity in the storyline despite a promising cast, including Allison Janney, Henry Golding, and others. With expectations high following the success of A Simple Favor, it remains to be seen if Another Simple Favor can carve out its own identity while appealing to the loyal fan base. The film is available for streaming on Prime Video as of May 1, 2025, allowing viewers a chance to dive back into this intriguing universe. As individuals watch and share their thoughts, the reception of the sequel may further evolve, influencing the potential of future collaborations between the filmmakers and the star-studded cast.