Former SNP MP criticizes party for taxing middle-earners in Scotland

Stewart McDonald, a former SNP frontbencher, has publicly criticized the Scottish National Party for its tax policies affecting middle earners. He argues that the party is alienating 'aspirational' Scots by imposing higher taxes than those in England. McDonald specifically calls for a reassessment of the tax bands for individuals earning between £26,562 and £75,000 annually, suggesting that the current approach is politically motivated rather than beneficial for the constituents. In his commentary, McDonald supports the idea proposed by former Scottish cabinet minister Alex Neil, advocating for a one-off land tax targeting the largest estates in Scotland as a more equitable solution. This proposal aims to alleviate the tax burden on middle earners while addressing wealth distribution in the country. The former MP's remarks come in light of a private meeting where First Minister John Swinney emphasized the need for the SNP to reconnect with middle-class and aspirational Scots. McDonald’s intervention highlights a growing concern within the party regarding its support base and the potential consequences of its current tax strategy. As the SNP faces criticism from within, the call for a new tax offer reflects a broader need for the party to reassess its policies to maintain support among key demographics. McDonald’s insights suggest that without significant changes, the party risks losing touch with a vital segment of the Scottish electorate.