Stephen Miller's anti-immigrant vision fails to reflect economic realities

On July 19, 2025, Deputy White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller appeared on Fox News, where he questioned what Los Angeles would look like if there were no illegal immigrants. He painted a vivid but unrealistic picture of the city, characterized by an abundance of resources, a lack of crime, and pristine streets. This portrayal sparked a critical response from observers, notably Caitlin Dickerson, who argued that Miller's view reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of economic principles. Moreover, Ray Suarez emphasized the critical role immigrants play in the U.S. economy, stating that there is a persistent labor shortage. He highlighted that the job market in the United States is in desperate need of workers, evidenced by the figurative '10 story high blinking neon help wanted sign.' The discussion highlights the broader issues surrounding immigration and labor, particularly in urban settings like Los Angeles, where immigrants are often essential in filling crucial roles that support local economies.