Navy Settles Lawsuit Over COVID-19 Vaccine Religious Exemptions

The U.S. Navy has reached a settlement with a group of current and former service members who were denied religious exemptions from the COVID-19 vaccine mandate. The settlement, announced by First Liberty Institute and Hacker Stephens LLP, represents approximately 4,300 sailors and Navy SEALs. Under the agreement, the Navy will re-evaluate personnel records to remove any negative documentation related to non-compliance with the vaccine mandate, including administrative separations and non-judicial punishments. In addition to the record review, the Navy has committed to publicly affirm its respect for religious service members and enhance training for commanders responsible for reviewing exemption requests. The settlement also includes a payment of $1.5 million in attorneys' fees. Danielle Runyan, chairwoman of the Military Practice Group at First Liberty Institute, expressed satisfaction with the outcome, emphasizing that service members who acted according to their conscience will not face career penalties. The legal battle began in November 2021 with a small group of Navy SEALs and evolved into a class action lawsuit after many service members were discharged for refusing the vaccine. The case highlights the broader implications of religious freedom within the military, as many exemption requests were denied, prompting legal challenges. Runyan noted that this case could set a significant precedent for future religious liberty claims in the military context. A Navy spokesperson referred inquiries to the Department of Justice for further comment.