Prosecutors required to consider race in plea deals in Minnesota county
- A new policy in Hennepin County mandates prosecutors to consider a defendant's race in plea agreements.
- The initiative aims to tackle persistent racial disparities in the local justice system.
- Critics raise concerns about the constitutionality and effectiveness of the directive.
In Hennepin County, Minnesota, on April 28, 2025, a new directive was issued by County Attorney Mary Moriarty, requiring that prosecutors consider a defendant's race when negotiating plea deals. This policy aims to address longstanding racial disparities in the criminal justice system. Moriarty argued that acknowledging factors such as racial identity and age is essential to pursuing fair and just outcomes. The directive has been met with mixed reactions, with some legal experts suggesting it could face constitutional challenges in the future. Critics concern over the implications of this directive in the context of broader national debates over diversity and equity initiatives, particularly as federal policies under former President Donald Trump have sought to limit such programs. Moriarty's decision follows scrutiny for her office’s handling of various high-profile cases, particularly her refusal to charge a state employee involved in vandalizing Tesla vehicles. Supporters of the policy maintain that addressing unconscious biases can lead to better justice outcomes, while opponents express skepticism about its legality and effectiveness in achieving equity. The policy stands as a significant moment in the ongoing evolution of criminal justice reform in the United States, highlighting divisions in public opinion on how race and justice intersect.