Debate Over Electronic Line Calling in Tennis

Starting in 2025, all ATP Tour-level events will implement Electronic Line Calling (ELC) to eliminate human error in line calls. However, a recent first-round match between American players Taylor Fritz and Brandon Nakashima highlighted potential flaws in the system. Despite the absence of line judges and the ability to challenge calls, a malfunction in the ELC system led to confusion and frustration on the court. Fritz experienced a moment of disbelief when a forehand he believed was out went uncalled by the ELC, leaving him in a precarious position at 30-40. The chair umpire, Greg Allensworth, informed Fritz that it was his responsibility to stop play if he thought the ball was out. This led to a heated exchange, with Fritz questioning the logic of needing to halt play when ELC was in use. He expressed his frustration, stating, “It’s actually ridiculous,” and former world No. 1 Andy Roddick echoed his sentiments on social media, calling the situation “allergic to common sense.” The rules dictate that if the chair umpire cannot determine the ball's status, the point must be replayed. In instances where no call is made and a player stops play, the umpire is required to display the shot on the video board for confirmation. Coco Gauff, who has also faced similar frustrations with umpire decisions at major tournaments, voiced her concerns about the reliability of officiating in high-stakes matches.