Renee Carroll: The Unsung Icon of Broadway's Cloakroom

Renee Carroll, who served as the hatcheck girl at Sardi’s restaurant in Manhattan for 24 years, carved out a unique niche in Broadway history. From her modest position in the cloakroom, Carroll mingled with a host of celebrity patrons, becoming a vital source of insider gossip that captivated newspaper columnists and theater enthusiasts alike. Her experiences and observations culminated in a popular book that humorously chronicled the quirks of stage actresses and the reactions of fading stars to the rise of newcomers like Joan Crawford. Despite the seemingly menial nature of her job, Carroll transformed her role into a platform for influence and creativity. She took pride in her work, viewing it as an opportunity to engage with the theatrical community. Carroll was known for her keen insights, often offering unsolicited critiques of play scripts left with her by patrons, showcasing her deep understanding of the theater world. Her interactions with notable figures, including playwright Eugene O’Neill, who once entrusted her with his wristwatch, further solidified her status as a beloved fixture in the restaurant. Carroll’s ability to blend her professional duties with a passion for theater allowed her to leave an indelible mark on the Broadway scene. As part of The Times' "Overlooked" series, Carroll's story highlights the remarkable lives of individuals whose contributions went unrecognized, reminding us that even those in the background can shape the cultural landscape in significant ways.