PETA proposes vegan cake to replace iconic groundhog as weather predictor

In the United States, on January 21, 2025, the animal rights organization PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) made a bold proposal regarding the traditional celebration of Groundhog Day. This event, which occurs annually in Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania, has featured Punxsutawney Phil, the groundhog, since its inception in 1887. PETA suggested that instead of using the live animal to predict the weather, the town should create a 'weather reveal' vegan cake which would indicate the season based on its color when sliced. A blue cake would signify six more weeks of winter, and a pink cake would indicate an early spring. This novel idea is reminiscent of gender reveal parties, where a cake is cut open to unveil a predetermined color signifying the baby's gender. PETA's push for a change to the long-standing tradition has sparked discussions and reactions from the community, including officials like Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, who defended the practice. PETA's president, Ingrid Newkirk, expressed concerns about the treatment of Phil, describing how the groundhog is subjected to stress each year, being transported and presented under noisy, bright conditions that clash with his natural instincts. Newkirk noted that if he were in his natural habitat, Phil would undoubtedly flee from such a situation, viewing it as a threat rather than an opportunity. This is not the first time PETA has made attempts to change the way Groundhog Day is celebrated. Previous suggestions have included using a giant coin for predictions, relying on a persimmon tree, and even substituting Phil with an animatronic version designed to forecast the weather more accurately than a live animal. Each of these ideas has been met with resistance from the Punxsutawney Groundhog Club, where members see Phil as a beloved fixture in their community, referred to by former president Jeff Lundy as 'the king of Punxsutawney'. He emphasized that Phil is well cared for in a certified agricultural zoo and receives regular veterinary attention, highlighting the care that goes into maintaining his health amidst the festivities. As Groundhog Day approaches, PETA's latest suggestion has reignited the debate over animal rights and how traditional practices can sometimes overlook the well-being of living beings involved. While the club has yet to formally respond to PETA’s letter, the ongoing dialogue reflects a growing awareness and concern for ethical treatment within public celebrations. Such debates may shape how traditions are upheld or transformed in the context of modern values and animal rights advocacy.