Bishop Burbidge supports secure immigration policies for human dignity

In a recent statement, Bishop Michael F. Burbidge of the Arlington diocese in Virginia addressed the ongoing immigration debate, asserting the need for secure borders and reasonable immigration limits. He emphasized that these principles do not conflict with human dignity. This stance is particularly relevant amid criticisms from various factions regarding immigration policies, including recent comments made by Vice President JD Vance on the Catholic Church's assistance to illegal immigrants. Burbidge underscored the Church's historical position on protecting both the rights of vulnerable individuals and the necessity of law enforcement, ensuring safety for all citizens, including immigrants. Bishop Burbidge's statement called for a balanced approach to immigration reform, where the dignity of individuals is preserved while also enforcing the rule of law. He emphasized the Church's duty to promote the common good, asserting that the Catholic teaching does not endorse an open-border policy. Rather, he urged the creation of an environment where responsibilities toward nations and the vulnerable can coexist without undermining public safety or legal compliance. The bishop acknowledged the existence of individuals in the country who have committed serious crimes, highlighting the importance of consequences for such actions. He stated that public order and safety are paramount, stating that laws must be respected to maintain societal harmony while affirming the imperative to care for all, including the vulnerable migrant families. Burbidge’s remarks come in the context of growing tensions within the Catholic Church regarding immigration policy and its alignment with Catholic doctrine. This tension has surfaced prominently during discussions about deportations and treatment of migrants in the U.S. His conciliatory tone suggests a willingness for dialogue between the Church and government authorities, aiming for common ground in safeguarding both human dignity and legal order. In light of various opinions within the Church hierarchy on these matters, Burbidge's call for secure borders seeks to foster a comprehensive immigration strategy that balances justice with mercy, ultimately prioritizing the common good.