Rami Malek's spy thriller falters under poor casting and dull script
- The Amateur, directed by James Hawes, follows a CIA decoder seeking revenge after his wife's murder.
- The film has received mixed reviews, with a 66% critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes but an 87% audience score.
- Critics highlight issues with casting and pacing, stating the film lacks the emotional depth to fully engage viewers.
The CIA spy thriller, featuring Rami Malek and Laurence Fishburne, recently debuted in theaters, revealing a multifaceted narrative of revenge and espionage. Set against a contemporary backdrop, the film follows Charlie Heller, played by Rami Malek, who is depicted as a brilliant yet introverted decoder for the CIA. His life takes a catastrophic turn when his wife is killed in a London terrorist attack, compelling him to embark on a perilous journey across the globe to seek justice. The film's plot sees Heller taking matters into his own hands after his superiors neglect to act on his intelligence about the terrorists. Despite the anticipation surrounding its release, the response from critics has been mixed. The initial rating on Rotten Tomatoes indicates a 66% approval from critics and an encouraging 87% audience score, suggesting that viewers may appreciate elements where critics found faults. While some praised the film's potential as a thrilling ride, others criticized its execution and pacing. The film's narrative has sparked discussions comparing it to the popular Jason Bourne series, though some reviews suggested it lacks the dramatic intensity and coherence commonly associated with high-stakes action thrillers. As audiences watched the film, reactions varied widely. Notable film critics have voiced their opinions, with some finding merit in its ambition and well-executed production elements. However, the characterization of Malek's role drew scrutiny, as several critics labeled his portrayal as a miscast, which detracted from the overall viewing experience. The action sequences, while occasionally thrilling, failed to sustain the tension needed for an engaging storyline. Ultimately, the film attempts to delve into deeper themes related to grief and revenge but struggles to deliver the emotional weight necessary to resonate with audiences. Critics pointed out flaws in the script that restricted character depth, leading to a viewing experience more perplexing than profound. Overall, while the film may have potential for entertainment, it ultimately leaves viewers questioning whether it achieved its artistic mission.