Feud on John Wayne's Movie Set

As "She Wore a Yellow Ribbon" celebrates its 75th anniversary, the film's production is remembered not only for its cinematic achievements but also for a notable feud between director John Ford and cinematographer Winton Hoch. The film, which is the second installment of Ford's Cavalry trilogy, features John Wayne as Captain Nathan Brittles, who embarks on his final mission before retirement. The film's legacy was solidified when Ford presented Wayne with a cake that read, “You’re an actor now,” after filming wrapped. Hoch's work on the film earned him the Best Cinematography Oscar in 1950, largely influenced by the cowboy art of Frederic Remington. However, the production faced significant challenges, particularly when inclement weather struck Monument Valley, where filming took place. Hoch expressed concerns about the lack of natural light and the potential danger posed by lightning to the crew and equipment, leading to tensions on set. Despite the reported feud, an eyewitness has downplayed the severity of the conflict. After a day of shooting, Wayne noticed an approaching storm and proposed to Hoch that they take advantage of the unique lighting conditions. Hoch ultimately agreed, indicating a willingness to collaborate despite earlier disagreements. The film remains a classic in the Western genre, showcasing the complexities of filmmaking and the relationships between its key players, while also highlighting the artistic vision that brought it to life.