Ranking Premier League clubs’ transfer windows: Who excelled and who faltered?

In a recent analysis, The Athletic assessed the transfer windows of Premier League clubs, ranking them from least to most successful. Newcastle United was criticized for their summer dealings, with Alan Shearer labeling their efforts as 'embarrassing.' The club's head coach, Eddie Howe, acknowledged that the squad is now weaker than the previous year, having made minimal impactful signings. This situation highlights the challenges faced by clubs with limited financial flexibility. Bournemouth's transfer window was marked by the significant loss of their best player, Dominic Solanke, who was sold to Tottenham Hotspur. Their major signing, Brazilian striker Evanilson, will need to adapt quickly to the Premier League to justify the £40 million investment. Meanwhile, Arsenal fans expressed disappointment over the lack of new striker acquisitions, relying instead on Chris Wood, which raises questions about their title ambitions. In contrast, West Ham United's transfer window was praised as one of the best in the league. The club made strategic moves, including the departure of Jadon Sancho and Mason Greenwood, which were seen as necessary for team improvement. This shift in recruitment strategy suggests a new direction for West Ham, aiming for greater competitiveness in the league. Overall, the rankings reflect a diverse range of outcomes for Premier League clubs during the transfer period, with some excelling while others struggled to make meaningful improvements to their squads.