Swalwell challenges Noem on authenticity of MS-13 tattoos photo

In a House hearing held on May 14, 2025, in Washington, D.C., Representative Eric Swalwell of California confronted Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem regarding a controversial photo associated with Kilmar Abrego Garcia, an El Salvadoran national recently deported by the Trump administration. The photo in question featured tattoos that allegedly belonged to Abrego Garcia and were claimed to be linked to the MS-13 gang. Swalwell raised concerns about the authenticity of the image, suggesting it may have been manipulated to exaggerate Abrego Garcia's criminal ties. This debate took place during a session examining the immigration enforcement policies of the Department of Homeland Security. During the exchange, Swalwell emphasized the need for authenticity and credibility in the information being used to justify such actions. He voiced his discontent that the focus of the hearing seemed placed upon the photo rather than on national security – a stance that Noem defended by arguing that the department's mission involves handling serious criminals who pose a threat to society. She categorized Abrego Garcia as a known member of a terrorist group and claimed that his deportation was a necessary measure for the safety of the U.S. Noem, however, refrained from confirming whether the image had been altered, deeming the inquiry unproductive amid the significant issues at hand. The hearing reflected broader tensions surrounding immigration policies under the previous administration and highlighted ongoing legal disputes regarding Abrego Garcia's deportation, which was deemed procedurally flawed by a judge earlier. The legal battle surrounding Abrego Garcia's status continues, as some contend that he should have been allowed to remain in the U.S. due to the dangers he would face if returned to El Salvador.