John Mulaney's return to Broadway raises eyebrows and sparks debate

In winter 2024, John Mulaney made a return to Broadway with a comedic show called 'All In: Comedy About Love', based on his friend Simon Rich's short stories. Mulaney, who previously debuted in a Broadway production in 2016, was quickly convinced to join the cast without even needing to read the script. Alongside Mulaney, the show features performers like Renée Elise Goldsberry, Richard Kind, and Fred Armisen, all of whom are set to be replaced by other notable names like Lin-Manuel Miranda and Jimmy Fallon as the production progresses. The performance showcases a blend of surreal narratives, including a love triangle featuring The Elephant Man and humorous personal ads created from the perspective of dogs. Mulaney expressed his enthusiasm for Rich's writing, emphasizing how well the stories adapt to stage performance, allowing actors to bring their personal interpretations to the characters. Director Alex Timbers collaborated with Rich to select appropriate stories for a 90-minute presentation that would engage audiences. The initial reading of the script lasted an exhausting 4.5 hours, prompting revisions and careful selection of stories that not only complemented each other thematically but also showcased the talents of the actors involved. The unique structure of the show allows each performer to remain seated with scripts, encouraging flexibility in delivery and interaction. Mulaney and Rich noted their excitement about attracting a younger audience to theater, hoping that the humor and relatability of the stories will convert some attendees into regular theatergoers. They believe this approach could foster a new appreciation for Broadway, bridging the gap between comedy fans and traditional theatrical experiences.