Kevin Smith and Netflix Release New Superbad Knockoffs in 2023

The era of Judd Apatow's studio comedies appears to be fading, yet his influence persists in contemporary films, particularly in the realm of teen comedies. Recent attempts to replicate the success of the iconic film Superbad have emerged, notably Kevin Smith's The 4:30 Movie and Netflix's Incoming. While these films draw inspiration from the familiar themes of one-crazy-night narratives and buddy dynamics, they struggle to capture the same magic that made Superbad a cultural touchstone. The 4:30 Movie is set in the mid-1980s and reflects the style of teen comedies from that era, paralleling the nostalgic elements found in Superbad. However, it lacks the depth and humor that characterized its predecessor. Incoming, on the other hand, seems to borrow from a broader range of teen films, including Can’t Hardly Wait and American Pie, but similarly falls short of delivering a fresh take on the genre. Despite the attempts to recreate the bromance and comedic elements that defined the Apatow era, these new films often miss the mark. They fail to acknowledge the nuanced friendships and emotional connections that made Superbad resonate with audiences. Instead, they lean into clichés and lack the sensitivity that has become more appreciated in modern storytelling. As the landscape of comedy evolves, it remains to be seen whether these films can find their footing or if they will be relegated to the growing list of unsuccessful Superbad knockoffs. The challenge lies in balancing humor with genuine character development, a feat that has proven difficult for many filmmakers in the current climate.