JD Vance warns Elon Musk against forming a third political party

In August 2025, JD Vance cautioned Elon Musk regarding his plans to form the America Party, suggesting that Musk would wield greater influence by remaining within the Republican Party. Vance expressed his thoughts during an interview on 'The Ingraham Angle,' where he emphasized the importance of loyalty to President Donald Trump's MAGA movement. Vance argued that Musk should work to improve the Republican Party from within instead of attempting to create a new political entity. This discussion arose as reports indicated that Musk had paused his plans for the America Party to refocus on his business ventures. Prior to this exchange, Musk had shared his views on the two-party system, expressing dissatisfaction and calling it a one-party system plagued by waste and graft. His motivations for considering a third-party initiative stemmed from his concerns about the political climate and its impact on the country. Although Musk's political ambitions have fluctuated, it seems he is now prioritizing his corporate responsibilities over political endeavors. The context of their conversation also included Musk's break from Trump over disagreements related to a significant spending bill, which Musk argued would exacerbate the national debt. Vance pointed out that Musk is now viewed as aligned with conservative values, making a return to the political middle ground unlikely. Moreover, Musk's historical support for Trump has been substantial, with significant financial contributions directed towards Republican candidates in the past election cycle. This commentary from Vance reflects a growing concern among some Republican figures regarding the implications of a potential third party, viewing it as a threat to party unity and electoral success. Commentators have varied opinions on whether a successful third party could emerge, but Vance's advice suggests that the current Republican leadership hopes to maintain alignment among its members. As the 2028 presidential election approaches, the dynamics between traditional party politics and Musk's influence will continue to unfold, shaping the future of American political discourse.