Charity warns against copying Italy’s migration policies to prevent Channel deaths

The International Rescue Committee (IRC), led by David Miliband, has criticized the UK government's approach to migration, particularly in light of recent tragedies in the Channel. Following a joint press conference where Labour leader Keir Starmer praised Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni for her migration policies, the IRC emphasized the need for safe routes for refugees rather than deterrence strategies that have proven ineffective. Starmer's comments came after a weekend marked by the loss of lives during dangerous crossings, highlighting the urgency of the situation. Meloni's government has made agreements with Albania and Tunisia to manage asylum claims and curb irregular migration. However, human rights organizations have raised concerns about the treatment of refugees in these countries, citing widespread abuse and detention. Francesca Saccomandi from Mediterranean Hope noted that while arrivals may have decreased, the dangers faced by those attempting the journey have not diminished, with many subjected to violence. The IRC's statement aligns with criticism from other organizations, including the Refugee Council and Amnesty, who argue that the focus should be on creating a compassionate and effective asylum system. They advocate for scaling up safe routes and investing in the asylum process to prevent further loss of life. In response, a Home Office spokesperson claimed that the UK already offers safe and legal routes for vulnerable individuals, asserting a commitment to restoring order in the asylum system. The ongoing debate reflects the complexities of migration policies and the need for humane solutions to address the crisis.