Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders claims Netflix's number one spot
- Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders has become Netflix's new number one, demonstrating its appeal regarding historical criminal investigations.
- Sirens was unseated after enjoying a successful run on the platform, highlighting shifting viewer interests.
- The series adds to the cultural dialogue on public safety and the legacy of unsolved cases in America.
In May 2025, the United States saw a shift in Netflix's top 10 list as a new show, Cold Case: The Tylenol Murders, claimed the number one position by displacing the miniseries Sirens. Sirens had maintained a strong presence among viewers but has now been unseated by the Cold Case series, which focuses on historical unsolved criminal cases, including this one from 1982, involving a nationwide crisis regarding cyanide-laced Tylenol. The horrific incidents resulted in at least seven deaths, and no one has ever been held accountable for these poisonings, which caused a significant public safety scare regarding over-the-counter medications. The Cold Case series lasts approximately 120 minutes and is structured into three parts, a format Netflix has adopted for similar storytelling projects. The fresh take on these enduring mysteries includes other high-profile unsolved cases like the murder of Jon Benet Ramsey, calling attention to the chilling nature of each unsolved narrative. Meanwhile, another show, She the People, gains traction with viewers as it sits fourth on the list. As this week unfolds, the impact of Cold Case is profound, bringing awareness to historical events that shaped public perception of product safety and consumer trust in the U.S.