Kane Cornes and Dale Thomas clash over controversial comments ahead of 2025

Kane Cornes, a commentator for Nine, has stirred controversy with his remarks about Port Adelaide player Zak Butters ahead of an important elimination final against Hawthorn. Cornes suggested that Butters, who has been dealing with rib pain, showed a lack of desire during a recent match, implying that he wanted to be substituted. This comment has drawn criticism from fellow commentator Dale Thomas, who advocates for supporting players and recognizing the challenges they face on the field. Despite the backlash, Cornes remains steadfast in his opinion, asserting that Butters will be a target for Hawthorn due to his injury. He emphasized that while players should not go outside the rules, they should take advantage of any opportunity to tackle Butters more aggressively. Cornes believes that this strategy is crucial in a high-stakes match like the upcoming final. Thomas, on the other hand, has taken a different stance, expressing his support for players and highlighting the difficulty of competing while injured. He acknowledges that there are times he agrees with Cornes but maintains that the focus should be on backing the players rather than criticizing them. As the two commentators prepare to work together in 2025, their differing views on player treatment and commentary style have sparked a public debate, showcasing the complexities of sports commentary and the responsibilities that come with it.