Colts win controversially with late penalty call against Broncos

In a high-stakes NFL game on Sunday, September 14, 2025, the Indianapolis Colts edged the Denver Broncos with a score of 29-28, marking their first 2-0 start since 2009. The game was characterized by its competitive nature, as both teams showcased impressive offensive strategies and strong performances themselves. Colts kicker Spencer Shrader had a difficult moment late in the game when his initial attempt at a 60-yard field goal fell short. However, the Broncos' Dondrea Tillman was penalized for leverage, giving Shrader another opportunity for a shorter 45-yard attempt. In the rollercoaster of emotions that followed, Shrader successfully converted the second attempt, securing the Colts' victory as time expired. The controversial call stirred debates among fans and analysts, prompting discussions about officiating decisions impacting crucial moments in the game. The Colts showcased their offensive prowess throughout the match, demonstrating tactical flexibility during the final drive where running back Jonathan Taylor carried the ball multiple times to gain yardage and set up Shrader's kicking attempts. Taylor finished the game with an impressive 165 rushing yards on 25 carries and also caught a touchdown pass, contributing significantly to the team’s success. Quarterback Daniel Jones played well, completing 23 of 34 passes for 316 yards and also scoring a touchdown on a 1-yard rush in what marked his second start with the Colts. His performance marked his first 300-yard game since joining the team, reflecting a significant upward trajectory in his performance metrics along with a clear understanding of the offensive strategy. Conversely, the Broncos, despite their loss, displayed formidable competitiveness with a strong outing from quarterback Bo Nix, who completed 22 of 30 passes for 206 yards and three first-half touchdowns. Running back J.K. Dobbins contributed with 76 rushing yards and a touchdown, helping the Broncos maintain pressure throughout the game. However, late penalties and crucial moments became the focal point as the game progressed, leading to a contentious finish that sparked conversations among fans about the impact of referees on the outcome of such critical matchups. Injuries also played a part in the game's atmosphere, with notable defensive players for both teams dealing with injury scares. Broncos cornerback Patrick Surtain II, a significant player last season, was temporarily sidelined with an ankle injury but returned to the game shortly thereafter. Colts left guard Quenton Nelson also faced a potential knee injury early in the game yet returned in the second half. The game concluded with the Colts setting up to face the Tennessee Titans in their next matchup, while the Broncos prepare for a challenging game against the Los Angeles Chargers. With this thrilling contest, the stage is set for many more intense battles ahead in this season’s NFL landscape.