CVS worker injured while helping security guard gets fired after filing for worker's comp

In New York City last fall, Abigail Downey, a CVS employee, was injured while assisting a security guard during a violent incident. After filing a worker's compensation claim for her jaw injury, she was terminated from her job within 24 hours. Downey's lawsuit claims that CVS used her injury as an excuse to avoid paying for her medical expenses, raising concerns about the company's commitment to employee safety.

CVS worker injured while helping security guard gets fired after filing for worker's comp
1 source
society Published Aug 2, 2026

Topic overview

In brief

  • Abigail Downey was injured while trying to help a security guard during a violent incident at CVS.
  • She filed a worker's compensation claim for her injuries but was fired shortly after.
  • The incident highlights serious concerns about employee safety and corporate priorities at CVS.

Summary

In a troubling incident that occurred last fall in SoHo, New York City, Abigail Downey, a 25-year-old CVS employee, suffered a severe jaw injury when she attempted to assist a security guard during a violent altercation with an erratic man. The assailant attacked both Downey and the security guard, leading to a chaotic scene that required police intervention. Following the incident, Downey filed a worker's compensation claim to cover her medical expenses, as the injury left her unable to chew food. However, within 24 hours of filing the claim, she was terminated from her position at CVS, with management citing 'escalating workplace violence' as the reason for her dismissal. Downey expressed her shock at the decision, stating that instead of showing concern for her injuries, her manager criticized her for leaving work early that night, approximately 30 minutes before her shift ended. The manager also claimed that Downey's possession of a personal taser in her bag was a factor in her firing, despite the fact that she did not use it during the assault. Downey's lawsuit alleges that CVS used this as a pretext to avoid paying for her injuries, highlighting a culture of neglect regarding employee safety in the store. She described the store as notorious for chaos and theft, indicating that CVS prioritized protecting merchandise over the safety of its employees and customers. Downey's lawyer criticized the company's approach, stating that it was fundamentally wrong for a corporation to focus more on inventory protection than on preventing foreseeable assaults. After her termination, Downey found employment with a competitor but maintained that she would act the same way again if faced with a similar situation. She expressed disappointment that those who did not intervene during the incident were not penalized, while she was punished for her attempt to help. This incident raises significant concerns about workplace safety and the responsibilities of employers to protect their employees in potentially dangerous situations.

Key entities

How Mestios works We aggregate coverage, extract key information, and use AI to summarize and compare perspectives. Learn more

Updated Aug 2, 2026

AI-generated summary. Please verify important information from original sources.