Cleveland Browns quarterbacks face harsh criticism from coaches and executives

In the United States, the Cleveland Browns are facing a quarterback competition during training camp. Coaches and executives have ranked both Deshaun Watson and Dorian Thompson-Robinson among the worst quarterbacks in the NFL. Watson's performance has declined due to injuries and a suspension, while Thompson-Robinson has been criticized for his inaccuracy. Despite the negative assessments, there is some optimism that new head coach Todd Monken could help improve their performances.

Cleveland Browns quarterbacks face harsh criticism from coaches and executives
1 source
sport Published Aug 5, 2026

Topic overview

In brief

  • The Cleveland Browns are currently in a quarterback battle during training camp.
  • Deshaun Watson and Dorian Thompson-Robinson have been ranked among the worst quarterbacks in the league.
  • Coaches and executives express skepticism about their abilities, but there is hope for improvement under new coach Todd Monken.

Summary

In the United States, the Cleveland Browns are currently engaged in a quarterback competition during their training camp. Recent evaluations from coaches and executives have revealed that both quarterbacks vying for the starting position, Deshaun Watson and Dorian Thompson-Robinson, are considered to be among the least effective in the league. Watson, once a highly regarded player, has seen his performance decline significantly due to injuries and a suspension, leading to his classification in the bottom tier of quarterbacks. Meanwhile, Thompson-Robinson has been criticized for his inaccuracy and inability to read defenses effectively.

The rankings, compiled by Mike Sando of The Athletic, categorize Watson and Thompson-Robinson in Tier 4, which includes unproven players and veterans who are not seen as reliable full-season starters. Watson's fall from grace is particularly notable, as he was once viewed as a Tier 1 quarterback in 2020 and 2021. His struggles have raised doubts about his ability to return to form, with some coaches expressing skepticism about his drive and processing skills. A former general manager even suggested that Watson's current status is so uncertain that he could be rated anywhere from Tier 3 to Tier 5.

Key entities

How Mestios works We aggregate coverage, extract key information, and use AI to summarize and compare perspectives. Learn more

Updated Aug 5, 2026

AI-generated summary. Please verify important information from original sources.