Topic overview
In brief
- The musical features a framing device with an older Neil Diamond discussing his life with a therapist.
- Will Swenson's performance as a young Neil Diamond is charismatic and engaging.
- Despite its flaws, the show entertains with memorable songs and a strong lead performance.
Summary
In a recent Broadway production, a jukebox musical featuring the songs of Neil Diamond has garnered attention for its lead performance. The show opens with an 85-year-old Diamond, portrayed by Terence Crawford, who expresses his struggles with life to a therapist. This framing device, while initially promising, becomes a repetitive element throughout the performance as the characters frequently interrupt the narrative to reflect on Diamond's emotional state. The book writer, Anthony McCarten, attempts to weave the songs into the storyline, but the execution often falls flat, leading to a lack of depth in character development.
Despite these shortcomings, Will Swenson's portrayal of a young Neil Diamond stands out. His performance is marked by charm and an expansive showmanship that captivates the audience, effectively overshadowing the flaws in the material. Swenson's ability to embody Diamond's vocal style while infusing his own warmth creates a compelling musical experience. The production features several of Diamond's classic hits, such as 'Sweet Caroline' and 'Holly Holy,' which serve as emotional high points in the show.